(Note: I first posted this review to my Goodreads account.)
TL;DR: This is Dracula in the world of Brother Cadfael. Dark and violent and not for everyone, but I liked it.
Okay, here's the longer review:
Have you ever read a book that made you feel:
1) I need to give lots of caveats before I recommend this book because, boy! it is NOT for everyone, BUT---
2) I really want to recommend this book, because there are some people who will LOVE it, and I don't want those people to miss it?
"No Moon To Pray To" is that kind of book. It's not going to be right for everyone, but I sure hope it finds the audience it's right for, because that audience is going to love it.
So, what are my caveats?
1) The theology isn't perfect. If I hadn't read a review by a reader I trusted, I would have put it down after the prologue.
2) It's violent. Like, very violent. And some of that violence involves children.
But, to counter those caveats, here are two corresponding notes:
1) I don't think the theology is perfect, but I do appreciate that it takes theology seriously. The theology MATTERS in this book, and I love that. (Also, much of the imperfect theology is seen through the eyes of clearly biased and compromised characters. So, it doesn't actually say much, if anything, about the theology of the author.)
2) The violence matters to the story, and it never feels like the author loves it or is wallowing in it. It's not voyeuristic. (I almost said it's not creepy, but...vampires are kinda necessarily creepy. "It's not TOLD creepily," might be a better and truer statement.)
So, with those caveats out of the way, who should read this? Who is that audience who shouldn't miss this book?
People who love the fantasy genre. People who want to read something that could be described as "Dracula as told in the world of Brother Cadfael." People who like something a little meatier in their speculative fiction. People who like it when novelists take Christianity (or any religion, really) seriously--that is, who think that what people believe actually makes a difference in the real world. Or, better yet, that you can tell what someone believes by what that person does. (At least sometimes. At least a little.)
People who want to read a page-turner. Because, if nothing else, "No Moon To Pray To" is definitely that.
I really liked it. I had trouble falling asleep the night I finished it because all the shadows seemed darker and scarier, true, but...I really liked it. Looking forward to seeing what Jerry Guern writes next.
Peace of Christ to you,
This post contains Amazon affiliate links; if you purchase a book from this link, I receive a small percentage of the purchase price. I will probably use it to buy more books. (See full disclosure on sidebar of my blog.)